HM Prison, Norwich: Execution History, Gallows, and Case Records

Norwich Castle had been the main prison for the County of Norfolk and the last execution there took place on the 13th of December 1886, when George Harmer was hanged for the murder of Henry Last, as documented in our detailed study of execution sites from the late 18th century to abolition in 1964.

The Prison Act of 1877 brought prisons under the control of the Home Office and led to the closure of a number of prisons that were no longer considered “fit for purpose” to use the modern expression.

The new county prison had been constructed on Knox Road, Norwich to the design of the surveyor to the Prison Department and built by Messrs W and T Denne, of Walmer, Kent during 1886 and early 1887.

It opened on the 16th of July 1887 and prisoners were transferred to it from the Castle on the 2nd of August.

At this time the prison was also referred to as Mousehold Prison, as it was built upon Mousehold Heath.

Local lore records that on the day when the men were marched in chains from the Castle to the new prison, officials went door to door beforehand to warn residents to stay indoors with their doors and windows locked.

The women were transferred in wagons.

As built it had accommodation for male and female prisoners.

The new prison comprised one long building with three floors of cells, the upper floors being reached by stairs leading to galleries, so that complete supervision by just three warders was possible.

The female inmates were transferred to Holloway Prison in December 1924 and the space created used to house male prisoners transferred from Ipswich Prison the following year. Ipswich Prison was then closed.


The Gallows at Norwich

The original gallows was set up in the coach house, where the prison van was housed, and the beam was wide enough to accommodate two prisoners, side by side.

In the event, the first two men who were sentenced to die at the new prison were both reprieved, and it would be nearly a decade before this gallows was actually used.

The location of the coach house is no longer known. It is probable that the first four executions were carried out here.

In the 1920s the Prison Commission had purpose-built condemned suites constructed in those prisons that were to continue to have executions.

As Ipswich Prison had closed, Norwich would be the hanging prison for both Norfolk and Suffolk.

It is likely that Herbert Bloye was the first to be hanged in the new facility, the contemporary newspapers reporting that his execution took just 30 seconds.

The later execution room adjoined what used to be the women’s wing, and local lore suggests that the condemned cell was in what used to be the women’s infirmary.

It is probable that the condemned cell opened into a short corridor that ran between the Governor’s Building and the Women’s Wing (it was also used for women to enter a sequestered corner of the Chapel).

The distance between this bricked-up door and the bricked-up entrance to the execution room, in a different coloured brick, is about 6 feet.

The execution room is on a level with the condemned cell, and there would have been a small flight of steps up to the scaffold which the condemned man would have been obliged to climb.

It is likely that there was also a pit, constructed in line with the evolution of the long drop in the 20th century, but all evidence of this has long been obliterated.

The places where the scaffold and beam were secured to the walls can be clearly seen.

An electricity sub-station was later installed in the gallows room.


Executions at Norwich

Twelve men were hanged here between July 1898 and July 1951, in ten individual executions and one double:

Prisoner NameExecution DateCrime and LocationExecutioner / Assistant
James (George) Watt12/07/1898Murder of wife Sophia at NorwichJames Billington & Thomas Billington
Herbert Bennett21/03/1901Murder of wife Mary at Great YarmouthJames Billington & Thomas Billington
James Nicholls24/11/1908Rape and murder of Susan Wilson at FeltwellHenry Pierrepoint & William Willis
Alfred Hewitt14/08/1912Murder of Sarah Wright at Downham MarketJohn Ellis & William Willis
Herbert Bloye16/08/1922Murder of wife at NorwichThomas Pierrepoint & Robert Baxter
Arthur Bishop14/08/1924Murder of Arthur Fabb at LowestoftThomas Pierrepoint & Robert Baxter
George Frusher30/12/1926Murder of wife at Terrington St. ClementRobert Baxter & Thomas Phillips
Frederick Fields18/12/1935Murder of Beatrice Ringer at NorwichThomas Pierrepoint & Alfred Allen
Roy L. Sly27/03/1940Murder of Olive Finch at Great YarmouthThomas Pierrepoint & Syd Dernley
Harold Berrett29/07/1941Murder of wife at Walpole St. AndrewAlbert Pierrepoint & Syd Dernley
Edward Trench29/07/1941Murder of daughter at NorwichAlbert Pierrepoint & Syd Dernley
Avtar Singh26/07/1951Murder of Jagat Singh at ThetfordAlbert Pierrepoint & Harry Allen

Notable Murder Cases

James Watt – “The Sprowston Murder” (1898)

James (also given as George) Watt shot and killed his wife Sophia Watt (née Marston) on the 14th of April 1898.

He had called on her at Denmark Terrace, Sprowston Road, Norwich and she told him that she was expecting another man.

This enraged Watt, who, having a pistol in his pocket, shot her.

Forty-four-year-old Watt was tried at the Norfolk Assizes which opened on Friday the 17th of June 1898 before Sir Henry Hawkins.

The evidence against him was overwhelming and the jury convicted him of wilful murder.

It would appear that Watt had systematically verbally and physically abused Sophia throughout the 22 years of their marriage.

In the condemned cell Watt was reportedly very penitent and confessed his crime to the prison chaplain, the Rev. S. W. Cox.

He also complained that some of the evidence against him was exaggerated and that he would not have committed the crime if he had been in his “right mind”.

Having been pinioned, Watt walked unaided to the gallows in a procession headed by the chaplain.

At 9:00 a.m. on the morning of Tuesday the 12th of July 1898, Watt was hanged by James Billington, assisted by his son, Thomas.

Death was reportedly “instantaneous”.

At this time the prison bell was still tolled and the black flag raised to show that the execution had been carried out.

An inquest was held by the Coroner, Mr. R. W. Ladwell, at 10:30 that morning.

Watt was buried in the prison grounds later that day in an eight-foot-deep grave.

Herbert Bennett – The Yarmouth Beach Murder (1901)

In 1896, 19-year-old Mary Jane Clarke met 16-year-old Herbert Bennett and, despite their families’ objections, they soon married.

They seemed to both engage in shady/criminal activities involving various frauds.

By 1900 they were living apart.

Mary had moved to rented accommodation at 1 Glencoe Villas in Bexleyheath in Kent with their three-year-old daughter, Ruby.

Bennett was living near his work at Woolwich Arsenal.

In an attempt to patch up the relationship, he offered to take Mary and their daughter on holiday to Great Yarmouth.

Mary and her child booked into the boarding house run by a Mrs. Rudrum in Row 104 between South Quay and Middlegate, on the 15th of September 1900, oddly using the name Mrs. Hood.

Each evening Mary went out and left Ruby with Mrs. Rudrum until Saturday the 22nd of September when she did not return and Mrs. Rudrum reported her missing.

The following morning, 14-year-old John Norton stumbled across a corpse as he was going for an early morning swim.

There was a mohair bootlace knotted tightly around the young woman’s neck.

Mrs. Rudrum was able to identify the victim and a search was made of Mary’s belongings.

They revealed a return train ticket to London and a laundry mark that could be traced to a laundry in Bexleyheath.

The laundry manager was able to provide the real name of the deceased as Mary Bennett.

Mrs. Rudrum remembered that Mary had received a letter bearing a Woolwich postmark.

A photograph was found that had been taken by a beach photographer showing a watch and chain on Mary that had gone missing.

This was found in Bennett’s possession when he was arrested seven weeks later.

He denied ever having been in Yarmouth, which could be shown to be a lie, as staff at the Crown and Anchor where he was staying identified him and told police that he had only got back to the hotel a few minutes before midnight on the Saturday night of the murder.

Items of jewellery belonging to Mary were missing and these had been given by Bennett to his new fiancée, 21-year-old parlourmaid Alice Meadows, to whom he had passed himself off as a bachelor.

The case produced a huge amount of public interest and Bennett’s defence lawyers successfully got the case moved from Norwich to London.

He came to trial at the Old Bailey from the 25th of February to the 2nd of March 1901, before the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Alverstone.

The prosecution alleged that Bennett took Mary and Ruby to Yarmouth so as to be able to rid himself of Mary, and thus be able to marry Alice.

The picture of the watch and chain was one of the first instances of the use of photographic evidence at a trial.

For the defence, Edward Marshall Hall produced Woolwich Arsenal shift records that showed Bennett was actually at work there 120 miles away when his wife was murdered.

A witness claimed he spoke to Bennett in London on the evening of the murder after the last train to Yarmouth had departed.

It was also alleged that Mary Bennett had been seen kissing a man near her lodgings on the eve of her murder.

Ultimately the jury preferred the prosecution’s case and convicted Bennett.

Bennett was transferred back to Norwich to await execution.

This was carried out on the morning of Thursday the 21st of March 1901 by James and Thomas Billington.

It was reported that Bennett struggled and twitched for two minutes after the trapdoors opened.

The flagpole up which the black flag was run to signify the execution had taken place snapped.

This was seen by some as an omen that an innocent man had been executed.

A view that would be further reinforced in July 1912 when the body of 18-year-old Dora May Green was discovered in a location near where Mary’s body had been found.

She had also been strangled with a bootlace. Her killer was never caught.

Postscript

Herbert Bennett’s case was re-examined by an Appeal Court judge as part of a BBC series which considered capital murder cases of the last century in light of modern forensic science.

All but one piece of evidence was upheld, and the evidence which did not stand up to modern scrutiny was deemed insufficient to render the conviction unsafe.

James Nicholls – “The Feltwell Murder” (1908)

Thirty-five-year-old James Nicholls was convicted at the Norfolk Assizes at Norwich on the 27th of October 1908 of the murder of 70-year-old Susan Wilson in her home at Ploughman’s Drove, Feltwell Fen in Norfolk.

The motive for the killing was rape. It took the jury just 20 minutes to reach their verdict.

It would appear that Nicholls was on bail at the time of the murder.

Mr. Justice Grantham then addressed Nicholls as follows:

“James Nicholls, the jury have unanimously arrived at the only verdict which was possible for them to come to.

I am quite sure that every one who has heard the evidence in this case has no doubt but that the case is absolutely clear and has been brought home to you.

It will be a terrible end for you, but looking at your past career, it is only the end that was likely to result for a man who has lived the life you have.

I find that in 1896 you were found guilty of unlawful wounding, in 1897 you were found guilty of rape, in 1901 I find you were guilty of attempted rape and beside that you have been convicted 22 times for game trespass and kindred offences.

But even that is not all. If it had not been that it was necessary for the Jury to try you on this painful case, you would have been charged before them or another Jury for rape committed last June, with reference to which the evidence was just as clear as we have listened to today.

As I have said before, we Judges particularly are most anxious to always let out prisoners on bail, when they have some time to wait for trial, especially in all cases where the character is not bad or where there is no probability of the prisoner making off. We always think that Magistrates would exercise a little discretion in letting prisoners out on bail.

We have to thank the Magistrates in this case for letting a man out on bail with such a character and you have to thank them for being at the present time sentenced to death. If you had not been kept in prison, as you ought to have been, you could not have committed this crime.

Looking at your past kindly, however, I think the evil day was only postponed. You have lived an unruly life and you have been a terror to the neighbourhood and you are now meeting your just deserts. I have only to pass the sentence of death.”

The killing took place on Sunday the 11th of October 1908.

Susan Wilson’s husband, Charles, was a travelling umbrella salesman who had been away from the village for four days.

He was returning home on this Sunday afternoon and arrived around 4:00 p.m., where he discovered Susan’s body.

She had been battered to death, assaulted, and strangled.

Nicholls was executed by Henry Pierrepoint, assisted by William Willis, on the 24th of November 1908.

Avtar Singh: The Final Execution (1951)

The final execution at Norwich Prison occurred on Thursday, the 26th of July 1951, when Avtar Singh was hanged for the murder of fellow countryman Jagat Singh at Thetford.

The execution was carried out by Albert Pierrepoint, assisted by Harry Allen.

Following Singh’s execution, the gallows at Norwich was never used again prior to the abolition of capital punishment in Britain in 1965.

Today, HMP Norwich remains an operational Category B/C adult male prison on Knox Road.


Frequently Asked Questions

When did HM Prison Norwich open on Knox Road?

HM Prison Norwich opened on July 16, 1887, on Knox Road across Mousehold Heath (often called Mousehold Prison). It replaced Norwich Castle Gaol, which closed following the Prison Act of 1877.

How many executions took place at HM Prison Norwich?

A total of twelve men were executed at Norwich Prison between July 1898 and July 1951: ten individual hangings and one double execution.

Where were the gallows located within Norwich Prison?

The first executions were conducted in the prison coach house, using a gallows beam wide enough for two prisoners. In the 1920s, a purpose-built execution suite was installed adjoining the former women’s wing, with the gallows room situated directly next to the condemned cell.

Who was Herbert Bennett, and why was his execution controversial?

Herbert Bennett was hanged on March 21, 1901, for the murder of his estranged wife Mary, whose body was discovered strangled with a bootlace on Yarmouth beach. Bennett insisted he was working at Woolwich Arsenal in London at the time of the murder. The snapped flagpole during the execution and the subsequent similar unsolved murder of Dora Green in 1912 reinforced claims of his innocence.

Who was the last person executed at Norwich Prison?

Avtar Singh was the final prisoner executed at HM Prison Norwich, hanged on July 26, 1951, by Albert Pierrepoint and Harry Allen for a murder committed in Thetford.


Support the Archive

If you have found this article useful and would like to help preserve and maintain this historical archive, please consider supporting the site.