Mary Ann Higgins was the 19-year-old niece of William Moore Higgins of Coventry and was described in contemporary newspaper reports as being:
“a rather good looking girl with fresh colour and a clear complexion, but not an intellectual countenance.”
When William’s brother died, he in effect adopted Mary and intended to leave her his savings in his will.
These were thought to amount to between £100 and £200, quite a large sum of money for the day.
Somewhere around the beginning of 1831, Mary met 21-year-old Edward Clarke, a watchmaker’s apprentice at Messrs. Vale and Co. in Coventry, and began a relationship with him which seemed to have quickly flourished.
Mary was aware of her uncle’s money and would steal from it for Edward, who was noted to suddenly have a lot more money than previously.
The Arsenic Poisoning of William Higgins
On the 22nd of March 1831, Mary tried to buy two pennyworth (1p) of arsenic from Wyly’s the chemists on the pretext of killing rats.
She was refused and told that she would need to return with a witness.
In Spon Street she met a girl she knew, Elizabeth Russell, who returned to the chemists with her, where she was now served.
The arsenic was wrapped in a paper and clearly labelled as “arsenic – poison”.
Edward came round in the evening and was in the house when William had some pea soup for dinner.
Soon after eating it, he began vomiting violently.
Around midnight, Mary went to fetch a neighbour, an elderly woman named Mrs. Green, who went back to the house and found William dead on Mary’s bed.
The following morning, Edward came round on his way to work to see how William was doing and was informed that he had died.
Another neighbour, Mrs. Moore, came round to help Mary clear up the house.
She found a bowl containing the uneaten portion of the pea soup in the pantry and gave it a stir, noting there was a distinct white substance settled in the bottom of the bowl.
She gave the bowl for safekeeping to the carpenter who had come to measure up for William’s coffin, and sent for a surgeon.
The surgeon opened William’s stomach, which he noted was intensely inflamed.
He took a sample of the stomach contents and sent it, along with the remaining pea soup, for chemical analysis.
The police were informed and took Mary into custody, where she initially denied everything, but later admitted that she had put two spoonfuls of arsenic into the basin before adding the soup.
The Inquest and Warwick Assizes Trial
At the coroner’s inquest, Mary attempted to shift the blame onto her boyfriend, stating:
“that Clarke had instigated her to take her uncle’s life; and that he (Clarke) had frequently beaten and ill used her when he did not have as much money from her as he wanted.”
A verdict of wilful murder was returned by the coroner’s jury, and the pair were committed for trial at the next Assizes.
The pair were tried together at the Warwick Assizes on Tuesday the 9th of August 1831.
Both were charged with the murder, and Edward Clarke was additionally charged with being an accessory to the crime.
Mary simply pleaded innocence and left what little defence she had to her legal counsel.
Edward Clarke submitted a lengthy written statement denying the charges and citing the vagueness of the circumstantial evidence against him.
Several reputable witnesses testified to his good character, whereas there were no character witnesses called for Mary.
The jury deliberated for just six minutes before acquitting Edward and convicting Mary.
Under the Murder Act 1752, which remained in force until 1836 (as examined in our introduction to the Bloody Code), she was sentenced to be hanged within 48 hours and her body delivered to surgeons for anatomical dissection.
She wept piteously, according to newspaper reports, while sentence was passed.
She was returned to the County Gaol in Pepper Lane in Coventry to await execution.
Execution on Whitley Common (11/08/1831)
Just before noon on Thursday the 11th of August 1831, Mary was placed into an open cart containing her own coffin, on which she sat for the journey of some two miles from Coventry Gaol to the New Drop gallows erected on Whitley Common (just off London Road), accompanied by the prison chaplain, the Rev. Mr. Paris.
Mary arrived at the gallows around 12:30 p.m.
Mr. Paris assisted her down from the cart and up the steps of the gallows, where she stood firmly on the trapdoor listening to his ministrations.
He shook hands with her before descending the scaffold, and Mary told him:
“The Lord Bless You.”
The executioner, William Calcraft, removed her bonnet and replaced it with a white hood.
He pinioned her arms and legs with cords, and upon her agreed signal of dropping a handkerchief, he withdrew the bolt under the short drop method.
She died after a brief struggle, and after hanging for the statutory one hour, her body was taken down and delivered to surgeons for dissection.
Her skull is preserved today in the Herbert Art Gallery & Museum in Coventry.
Mary Ann Higgins holds the historic distinction of being the last person executed on Whitley Common and the last condemned prisoner taken by cart to the gallows in England and Wales.
All other English counties had by this time transferred executions to permanent or portable scaffolds situated directly at their County Gaols, as documented in our historical survey of execution sites from the late 18th century to abolition in 1964 and Stafford Prison.
Executions at Coventry in the 19th Century
Executions were rare events at Coventry, with only six in total taking place there during the entire nineteenth century:
- 1800: Two men hanged together for forgery under the Bloody Code.
- 1821: Two men executed for burglaries.
- 11 August 1831: Mary Ann Higgins, hanged on Whitley Common for the arsenic murder of her uncle.
- 9 August 1849: Mary Ball, who became the final person executed in Coventry, hanged in front of the County Hall for poisoning her husband.
Analytical Commentary
It is difficult to determine from reading the contemporary newspapers what precise role Edward Clarke played in the crime—whether he actively instigated it and coerced Mary, or whether Mary committed the murder entirely on her own initiative without his knowledge to gain immediate control of the inheritance so that they could marry.
There seems little reason to doubt that Mary, and Mary alone, physically administered the fatal dose of arsenic.
The execution of a 19-year-old girl was certainly not headline news in 1831, and no organized petition was made to obtain an executive reprieve for her.
Her trial and punishment reflected the strict, unyielding application of capital statutes to female poisoners in early 19th-century Britain, long before the transition to the evolution of the long drop in the 20th century and the final passage of the abolition of capital punishment in Britain in 1965.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who was Mary Ann Higgins?
Mary Ann Higgins was a 19-year-old domestic servant from Coventry who was convicted of murdering her adoptive uncle, William Moore Higgins, with arsenic in March 1831 to obtain his savings.
Why is the execution of Mary Ann Higgins historically significant?
She was the last person executed on Whitley Common in Coventry and the last prisoner in England and Wales to be conveyed by cart to an open execution site rather than being hanged directly at a county gaol.
Who was Edward Clarke?
Edward Clarke was a 21-year-old watchmaker’s apprentice and Mary Ann Higgins’s boyfriend. Although Mary claimed he pressured and beat her to obtain money and instigated the poisoning, Clarke was acquitted by the Warwick Assizes jury in just six minutes due to character references and lack of direct evidence.
What method of execution was used?
Mary Ann Higgins was hanged on a New Drop gallows by London executioner William Calcraft on August 11, 1831. Under the Murder Act 1752, her body was suspended for one hour and then delivered to surgeons for anatomical dissection.
Where is Mary Ann Higgins’s skull today?
Her skull was retained following anatomical dissection and is preserved in the collections of the Herbert Art Gallery & Museum in Coventry.
Support the Archive
If you have found this article useful and would like to help preserve and maintain this historical archive, please consider supporting the site.