Ruth Ellis – The Last Woman to Hang in Britain

Ruth Ellis, the last woman to be hanged in the UK, has always been portrayed as the victim of a cruel boyfriend who abused her and a cruel legal system that hanged her. But is this really an accurate picture? Based upon the known facts, which are very well documented, I propose to take an “alternative” look at this famous case.

On Wednesday, the 13th of July 1955, at London’s Holloway Prison, she secured her place in history, becoming the 18th and last woman to be executed in Britain in the 20th century. Her case is memorable because she was hanged; had she been given a life sentence, she would have been forgotten in a few weeks by most people.

Background

Ruth Hornby was born in the seaside town of Rhyl in North Wales on the 9th of October 1925, the third of six children. She attended Fairfields Senior Girls’ School in Basingstoke, leaving when she was 14 to work as a waitress. In 1941, the Neilsons moved to London.

During 1944, 17-year-old Ruth became pregnant by a married Canadian soldier named Clare and gave birth to a son, whom she named Clare Andria Neilson. The father sent money for about a year, then stopped. The child eventually went to live with her mother.

Ruth became a model and also a nightclub hostess, working initially at the Court Club in Duke Street, where she met, and on the 8th of November 1950 married, dentist George Johnston Ellis. In 1951, she gave birth to a daughter, Georgina, whom George refused to acknowledge. The couple split up soon afterwards, and Ruth went back to nightclub work, becoming the manager of the Little Club in 1953.

This was a popular club with the motor racing fraternity, and it was here that she met 25-year-old former public schoolboy David Drummond Moffat Blakely, who was trying to build a racing car with his friends, the Findlaters. He was soon living with Ruth in her flat above the club, and they had a passionate and tempestuous relationship, which led to physical violence on occasions. During one of these altercations, in January 1955, he punched her in the stomach, which caused her to miscarry. David was known to be a heavy drinker and was jealous of Ruth’s flirting with other club members, as she was of his other relationships.

Ruth began seeing Desmond Cussens, who was some four years her senior. He had been a bomber pilot during World War II and, when Ruth knew him, was a director of Cussens & Co. She lived with Desmond for a time but continued to see David as well.

The Crime

As stated above, David was building a racing car with Ant Findlater and, over Easter weekend of 1955, consistently refused to see her, having promised to do so, and despite repeated visits and phone calls by Ruth to the Findlaters’ home. They had, unfortunately, taken on a nanny whom Ruth suspected David was having an affair with, although in truth he wasn’t.

So, in a pique of jealousy and rejection on Easter Sunday afternoon (the 10th of April 1955), Ruth persuaded Desmond to drive her to Hampstead, where she lay in wait for David outside the Magdala public house in South Hill Park, where he and Findlater were drinking.

When they came out to the car at around 9.30 p.m., she called out to David, who ignored her. Armed with a .38 calibre Smith & Wesson revolver, she fired a first shot and then pursued him round the car, firing a second shot, which caused him to collapse onto the pavement. She then stood over him and emptied the remaining four bullets into him as he lay wounded on the ground. At least one bullet was fired from point-blank range and left tell-tale powder burns on his skin. One bullet injured a Mrs. Gladys Yule in the thumb as she was walking up to the pub with her husband and who witnessed the murder from around 20 yards away.

Other drinkers came out of the pub to see what had happened, and Ruth was arrested by an off-duty policeman, Alan Thompson, still holding the gun. Mr. Thompson would later testify that he had seen a woman’s face at a window of the pub and, a few minutes later, heard two shots.

Ruth was taken to Hampstead police station, where she appeared to be calm and not obviously under the influence of drink or drugs, which she is alleged to have been taking by some on the afternoon prior to the shooting. She made a detailed confession to the police and was charged with murder.

Committal and Remand

Ruth appeared at a special hearing of Hampstead Magistrates’ Court on Easter Monday, the 11th of April, where she was remanded in custody to Holloway Prison to await trial. She was placed in the hospital wing and kept under observation day and night. During her initial interview on the Monday afternoon, she again described the details of David’s killing.

The Principal Medical Officer, Dr. Mervyn Ralph Penry Williams, examined her and interviewed her twice, finding no evidence of mental illness. Ruth consented to and undertook an electroencephalograph examination on the 3rd of May. This also failed to find any evidence of brain abnormality.

While on remand in Holloway, she was also examined by Dr. D. Whittaker, a psychiatrist for the defence, on the 4th of June, and by Dr. A. Dalzell on behalf of the Home Office on the 9th of June. Neither man found any evidence of insanity. Ruth discussed her feelings on the days leading up to, and including, the murder with Dr. Dalzell, and he reported to the Home Office that he found no evidence of delusions, hallucinations, or other form of mental illness.

These examinations were required by law to ensure that Ruth was legally sane and therefore fit to plead at her trial. Under the Trial of Lunatics Act of 1883, where evidence existed of insanity at the time the crime was committed, the accused was to be committed to Broadmoor at Her Majesty’s Pleasure. Some 428 people were found to be insane out of 3,130 people (13.6%) who were committed for trial for murder between 1900 and 1949.

The Trial

Her trial opened on Monday, the 20th of June 1955, in the Old Bailey’s No. 1 Court before Mr. Justice Havers. The prosecution was led by Mr. Christmas Humphries, assisted by Mervyn Griffith-Jones and Miss Jean Southworth, whilst the defence was led by Mr. Aubrey Melford Stevenson, assisted by Mr. Sebag Shaw and Mr. Peter Rawlinson.

Ruth appeared in the dock in a smart black two-piece suit and white blouse, her hair re-dyed to her preferred platinum blonde in Holloway with the special permission of Dr. Charity Taylor, Holloway’s governor. Hardly the image of the poor, downtrodden woman!

She pleaded not guilty, apparently so that her side of the story could be told, rather than in any hope of acquittal. She particularly wanted disclosed the involvement of the Findlaters in what she saw as a conspiracy to keep David away from her.

In her defence she testified that, “He (David) only hit me with his fist or hands. I bruise easily.” She also described her recent miscarriage of a two-month-old foetus: “A few weeks or days previously, I do not know which, David got very violent. I do not know whether that caused the miscarriage or not. He thumped me in the tummy.”

When the prosecuting counsel, Mr. Christmas Humphreys, asked her, “Mrs. Ellis, when you fired that revolver at close range into the body of David Blakely what did you intend to do?” she replied, “It was obvious that when I shot him I intended to kill him.” So the jury were presented with an admission to the shooting plus the all-important admission of intent to kill.

There were legal submissions made by Mr. Melford Stevenson, KC, counsel for the defence, regarding provocation. Mr. Justice Havers said he had given careful consideration to these but ruled that there was “insufficient material, even upon a view of the evidence most favourable to the accused, to support a verdict of manslaughter on the grounds of provocation.”

Mr. Melford Stevenson said that, in view of that ruling, it would not be appropriate for him to say anything more to the jury.

The jury were then brought back into court, and in their presence Mr. Melford Stevenson said, “In view of the ruling which your Lordship has just pronounced I cannot now with propriety address the jury at all, because it would be impossible for me to do so without inviting them to disregard your Lordship’s ruling.”

Mr. Christmas Humphreys indicated that, in the circumstances, he would not make a final speech to the jury either.

The judge then summed up. After reviewing the evidence for the prosecution, his Lordship said: “You will remember that when Mr. Stevenson made his opening address to you he told you that he was going to invite you to reduce this charge of killing from murder to manslaughter on the grounds of provocation.

“The House of Lords has decided that where the question arises whether what would otherwise be murder may be reduced to manslaughter on the grounds of provocation, if there is not sufficient material, even upon a view of the evidence most favourable to the accused, that a reasonable person could be driven by transport of passion and loss of control to use violence and a continuance of violence, it is the duty of a judge, as a matter of law, to direct the jury that the evidence does not support a verdict of manslaughter. I have been constrained to rule in this case that there is not sufficient material to reduce this killing from murder to manslaughter on the grounds of provocation. It is therefore not open to you to bring in a verdict of manslaughter on the grounds of provocation.”

Referring to the evidence for the defence, the judge said: “This court is not a court of morals, this is a criminal court and you should not allow your judgement to be swayed or your minds to be prejudiced in the least degree against the accused because according to her own admission she had committed adultery, or because she was having two persons at different times as lovers. Dismiss those matters wholly from your minds.”

Mr. Justice Havers continued, “But I am bound to tell you this, that even if you accept every word of Mrs. Ellis’ evidence there does not seem to be anything in it which establishes any sort of defence to the charge of murder.”

The jury then retired and, not surprisingly, found Ruth guilty after deliberating for only 23 minutes. It was hard to see how any other verdict was possible.

To convict a person of murder, two things have to be proved: (1) that the person actually killed the victim (known in law as the “actus reus,” or the “guilty act”) and (2) that they intended to kill the victim (known as the “mens rea,” or the “guilty mind”). Clearly there was no question as to whether Ruth had actually killed David Blakely, and by her famous answer to the question as to her intention when she fired the shots, there could be no question as to her intent. If it had been possible to show diminished responsibility under the law as it stood then, the outcome might have been different, but that defence did not exist prior to the Homicide Act of 1957.

In the Condemned Suite at Holloway

Ruth was taken back to Holloway to await execution, which was scheduled for the 13th of July. She was housed in the condemned cell in the hospital wing and placed under constant surveillance by two prison wardresses.

During her time in the condemned cell, she remained largely composed and cooperative. She wrote letters to her family and to David’s mother, expressing sorrow for the grief she had caused. A petition for a reprieve was organised, gathering thousands of signatures, and was submitted to the Home Secretary, Major Gwilym Lloyd George. However, the Home Secretary decided that the law must take its course and refused to recommend a reprieve.

Execution

At 9:00 a.m. on Wednesday, the 13th of July 1955, Ruth Ellis was led to the execution chamber adjoining her cell. The execution was carried out by Albert Pierrepoint, assisted by Royston Rickard.

The procedure was carried out swiftly in accordance with the established Home Office routine. Outside the gates of Holloway Prison, a large crowd of around 1,000 people had gathered, with many demonstrating against capital punishment. As required by statute, an inquest was held later that morning before the coroner, and her body was subsequently buried in an unmarked grave within the prison grounds.

Legal Aftermath and Modern Re-evaluation

The execution of Ruth Ellis provoked intense public and political debate across Britain. The public unease surrounding her hanging, following closely after the controversial executions of Derek Bentley and Timothy Evans, became a powerful catalyst for the reform of British homicide law.

Two years later, Parliament passed the Homicide Act 1957, which created the defence of diminished responsibility and restricted capital murder to specific categories, ultimately paving the way for the Murder (Abolition of Death Penalty) Act 1965.


Support the Archive

If you have found this article useful and would like to help preserve and maintain this historical archive, please consider supporting the site.