The Execution of Amber McLaughlin

Post-Furman US execution #1558

Missouri execution #94 since reinstatement

On Tuesday, the 3rd of January, 2023, the State of Missouri carried out the first execution in the United States for that year when 49-year-old Amber McLaughlin—listed in official court and penal records under her birth name, Scott A. McLaughlin—was put to death by lethal injection at the Eastern Reception, Diagnostic and Correctional Center in Bonne Terre, St. Francois County. McLaughlin had spent more than sixteen years on death row following conviction for the 2003 rape and murder of an ex-girlfriend in suburban St. Louis.

The case attracted widespread domestic and international press attention because McLaughlin was the first openly transgender person to be executed in modern American history. In addition, the proceedings renewed debate surrounding Missouri’s statutory sentencing provisions, which permit a trial judge to impose capital punishment when a sentencing jury deadlocks.

The Crime

The victim in the case was 45-year-old Beverly Guenther, who lived in Earth City, St. Louis County, and worked as an office administrator.

In 2003, McLaughlin (then living as a male) had been in a relationship with Miss Guenther. Following the termination of the relationship, McLaughlin subjected Miss Guenther to persistent harassment and stalking, repeatedly appearing at her place of employment and concealing herself on the property. Miss Guenther had secured an order of protection from the local circuit court, and police officers routinely provided escorts to her vehicle at the close of the working day.

On the evening of Thursday, the 20th of November, 2003, Miss Guenther left her office unaccompanied. McLaughlin ambushed her beside her parked vehicle, dragging her away before she could raise an alarm. Later that evening, neighbours contacted authorities when she failed to arrive home. Police officers responding to the Earth City office complex discovered a trail of blood and a broken knife handle near Miss Guenther’s car.

The following day, McLaughlin was located and detained by investigators. During subsequent questioning, McLaughlin admitted to the abduction and directed detectives to a secluded stretch of marshland along the Mississippi River in north St. Louis. There, police recovered Miss Guenther’s body. Post-mortem examination revealed that she had been forcibly raped and stabbed multiple times in the neck and chest.

Trial and Sentence

McLaughlin was indicted in St. Louis County on charges of first-degree murder, forcible rape, sexual assault, and armed criminal action.

The trial took place in October and November 2006. Physical evidence presented by the prosecution was conclusive, including DNA evidence linking McLaughlin to the sexual assault, blood evidence from the vehicle, and McLaughlin’s personal disclosure of the burial site. On the 3rd of November, 2006, the jury returned a verdict of guilty on all counts.

During the subsequent penalty hearing, the jury heard arguments regarding statutory aggravating factors. However, after deliberations, the jury was unable to agree unanimously on a sentence of death or life imprisonment without parole. Under Missouri law (and Indiana law), if a capital sentencing jury deadlocks, the responsibility falls upon the presiding trial judge to independently weigh the evidence and impose either a life sentence or the death penalty. St. Louis County Circuit Judge Steven Goldman found that the statutory aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating factors and formally sentenced McLaughlin to death.

Appeals and Gender Transition

McLaughlin was transferred to death row at the Potosi Correctional Center. While incarcerated, McLaughlin initiated a gender transition to female, adopting the first name Amber. However, no formal petition for a legal name change had been filed, and state court dockets, death warrants, and correctional tracking continued under the legal name Scott McLaughlin.

Appellate lawyers pursued federal habeas corpus relief, arguing that trial counsel had rendered ineffective assistance by failing to investigate and present expert evidence regarding severe childhood trauma, neurological impairment, and major depression. In 2016, a federal district judge vacated the death sentence, ruling that McLaughlin had been deprived of effective legal representation during the penalty phase. However, the state appealed, and in August 2021, a three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit reversed the district court’s decision, reinstating the sentence of death.

A comprehensive clemency petition was submitted to Governor Mike Parson, emphasising McLaughlin’s severe childhood abuse—which included beatings with police implements by an adoptive father—and arguing that the sentence had been handed down by a judge rather than a unanimous jury. On the morning of the 3rd of January, 2023, Governor Parson officially rejected the application, citing the premeditated and violent nature of the murder. A final petition to the United States Supreme Court was denied without dissent.

The Execution

McLaughlin was moved to the Eastern Reception, Diagnostic and Correctional Center at Bonne Terre on the eve of the execution. She declined a special last meal and made no request beyond the standard prison fare.

Shortly before 6:30 p.m. on Tuesday, the 3rd of January, 2023, McLaughlin was secured to the gurney in the lethal injection chamber. Intravenous lines were introduced into both arms. Behind the glass partition, official witnesses and a spiritual adviser were in attendance.

When asked if there were any final oral remarks, McLaughlin made none. A short, typed final statement, signed “Scott McLaughlin,” was released by prison authorities following the procedure:

“I am sorry for what I did. I am a loving and caring person.”

The execution team initiated the intravenous injection of a single five-gram dose of pentobarbital at 6:39 p.m. McLaughlin spoke quietly with the spiritual adviser positioned beside the gurney, moved slightly, and took several shallow breaths before drifting into unconsciousness. All outward respiration ceased within four minutes, and no visible physical distress was observed.

An examining physician formally pronounced life extinct at 6:51 p.m. Central Time. McLaughlin was 49 years of age. In accordance with McLaughlin’s prior written wishes, the remains were released for cremation


Support the Archive

If you have found this article useful and would like to help preserve and maintain this historical archive, please consider supporting the site.