Post-Furman US execution #1597
Missouri execution #100 since reinstatement
On Tuesday, the 24th of September, 2024, the State of Missouri carried out its one-hundredth execution in the post-Furman era when 55-year-old Marcellus Williams was put to death by lethal injection at the Eastern Reception, Diagnostic and Correctional Center in Bonne Terre, St. Francois County. Williams had spent over twenty-three years on death row following his conviction for the 1998 murder of a former newspaper reporter in University City, St. Louis County.
The execution attracted worldwide protest and extraordinary legal controversy, principally because the sitting county prosecuting attorney had actively sought to vacate the conviction on grounds of flawed forensic evidence and juror discrimination, whilst the victim’s surviving family had formally requested that his life be spared.
The Crime
The victim in the case was 42-year-old Felicia “Lisha” Gayle, a former reporter for the St. Louis Post-Dispatch who had left journalism to engage in local charitable and volunteer work. She lived with her husband, Dr. Daniel Picus, in a residential neighbourhood of University City.
On the afternoon of Tuesday, the 11th of August, 1998, Dr. Picus returned home from work around 8:00 p.m. to discover his wife’s body lying at the foot of the stairs. She had sustained forty-three stab and incision wounds inflicted with a large butcher’s knife taken from her own kitchen, with the weapon left embedded in her neck. Her handbag, a jacket, and her husband’s laptop computer had been taken from the residence, and an upstairs window pane near the entrance had been broken to gain entry.
The murder remained unsolved for more than a year. In 1999, authorities received statements from two informants. Henry Cole, who had shared a cell with Williams while the latter was held at the St. Louis City Workhouse on an unrelated armed robbery charge, claimed that Williams had confessed to the killing while watching a television broadcast about the crime. Subsequently, Laura Asaro, an ex-girlfriend of Williams, approached police alleging that on the day of the homicide, Williams had worn an unseasonable jacket concealing bloody clothing and scratches. She further asserted that she had discovered Miss Gayle’s purse and identification card in the boot of his automobile. Police subsequently traced the stolen laptop to a third party, who testified that he had received it from Williams in exchange for cash.
Williams was formally indicted for first-degree murder, first-degree burglary, first-degree robbery, and two counts of armed criminal action in November 1999.
Trial and Sentence
Williams was tried in the St. Louis County Circuit Court in Clayton in May and June 2001.
The state’s case rested primarily upon the testimony of Cole and Asaro, alongside Williams’s possession and sale of the victim’s laptop. Notably, no physical trace evidence gathered from the crime scene—including latent fingerprints, bloody shoe impressions, and hairs—matched Williams, and DNA recovered from under the victim’s fingernails did not correspond to him. The defence argued that both Cole and Asaro were motivated by a substantial $10,000 reward offered in the case and the promise of leniency regarding their own pending criminal charges.
On the 6th of June, 2001, the jury—comprising eleven white jurors and one Black juror after the prosecution struck several prospective Black candidates—found Williams guilty on all counts. Following the penalty hearing, the jury recommended a sentence of death for the murder, which was formally imposed by the trial judge on the 27th of August, 2001.
Prolonged Appeals and DNA Controversy
Williams spent over two decades at the Potosi Correctional Center, during which he converted to Islam, adopted the name “Khaliifah,” and served as an imam to fellow inmates. He consistently maintained his innocence of the murder.
His execution was stayed twice: first by the Missouri Supreme Court in 2015 for advanced DNA testing, and again in August 2017 by then-Governor Eric Greitens, merely hours before the scheduled execution. Governor Greitens appointed a Board of Inquiry composed of five retired judges to review newly developed DNA testing of the murder weapon, which showed an unknown male DNA profile that did not match Williams.
The matter remained unresolved for nearly six years until June 2023, when Governor Mike Parson abruptly dissolved the Board of Inquiry without receiving a final report, allowing the Missouri Supreme Court to assign a new execution date.
In January 2024, the newly elected Prosecuting Attorney for St. Louis County, Wesley Bell, filed a formal motion under a state statute to vacate Williams’s conviction, citing doubts over the integrity of the original verdict. However, during an evidentiary hearing in August 2024, fresh testing revealed that the DNA profile on the knife handle matched the original trial prosecutor and an investigator, who had handled the weapon without gloves prior to trial, thereby destroying any potential touch-DNA left by the perpetrator.
Faced with the contamination of the physical evidence, Williams agreed to enter an Alford plea to first-degree murder in exchange for a sentence of life imprisonment without parole—an agreement consented to by both the prosecutor and the victim’s family. However, the Missouri Attorney General’s Office immediately appealed against the arrangement, and the Missouri Supreme Court blocked the plea agreement, directing the lower court to hold a final hearing. The circuit court ultimately upheld the conviction, finding that the remaining circumstantial evidence was sufficient.
The Execution
On Monday, the 23rd of September, 2024, both the Missouri Supreme Court and Governor Mike Parson rejected final appeals for clemency. On the afternoon of Tuesday, the 24th of September, the United States Supreme Court declined to intervene, with Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan, and Ketanji Brown Jackson noting their dissents.
For his final meal, Williams requested chicken wings and tater tots. In his final written statement released prior to the execution, he wrote simply:
“All Praise Be To Allah In Every Situation!!!”
Williams was escorted into the execution chamber at the Eastern Reception, Diagnostic and Correctional Center shortly before 6:00 p.m. Secured to the gurney, he was attended by his spiritual adviser, who sat beside him and engaged in quiet prayer. Members of his legal team and his son watched through the witness windows; no members of Miss Gayle’s family attended.
The intravenous administration of a fatal dose of pentobarbital commenced at 6:01 p.m. Williams appeared to converse briefly with his imam, moved his feet slightly beneath the sheet, and exhaled heavily several times before chest movements ceased. He showed no prolonged signs of physical distress.
An examining physician formally pronounced life extinct at 6:10 p.m. Central Time. Marcellus Williams was 55 years of age.
Following the execution, the St. Louis County Prosecuting Attorney issued a statement expressing profound regret that the sentence had been carried out, while Governor Parson defended the outcome, stating that over two decades of judicial reviews had affirmed the original jury’s verdict. Williams’s execution stood as one of the most widely debated capital cases of the modern American era.
Support the Archive
If you have found this article useful and would like to help preserve and maintain this historical archive, please consider supporting the site.