The Toa Payoh Ritual Murders in Singapore

Singapore is hardly noted for being a lawless country—in fact, quite the opposite—so it is not hard to imagine the public’s shock, followed by fascination, with the gruesome murders of two small children in 1981 that would send three people to the gallows seven years later.

The trio comprised Adrian Lim (46), his wife Catherine Tan Mui Choo (34), and his mistress Hoe Kah Hong (33) (ages at the time of execution).


Background of the Case and Perpetrators

Adrian Lim

Adrian Lim was born on the 6th of January 1942, the eldest of three children.

He attended the Anglo-Chinese School, but dropped out in his later teens.

After leaving school, he worked for a few months as an Internal Security Department informer, later joining the Rediffusion television company where he would spend the next 14 years working as a bill collector.

He married and had two children with his first wife, who divorced him in 1976 for having an affair with Catherine Tan Mui Choo.

Lim and Tan married in 1977.

Lim became interested in becoming a medium and was given training by a local bomoh known as “Uncle Willie”.

A bomoh is a spiritualist and faith healer, a tradition also seen in Southeast Asian occult crimes such as the Mona Fandey case in Malaysia.

Lim appears to have been very successful in luring wealthy clients into his web and was able to give up his day job with Rediffusion to live entirely off his work as a medium.

Catherine Tan Mui Choo

Catherine Tan Mui Choo was 24 years old when she met Lim, having been referred to him by a fellow bar girl.

She was the eldest of four children.

Like Lim, she was not a great student and as a teenager had been sent to the Catholic charity Marymount Vocational Centre (then a home for troubled juveniles).

Tan was largely rejected by her parents and suffered from depression.

At the time of their meeting, she was grieving the death of her grandfather.

She loved the attention Lim gave her, even though he mistreated her, was regularly unfaithful, and even prostituted her out to other men.

Hoe Kah Hong

Hoe Kah Hong was born on the 10th of September 1955, the third of six children, and had lost her father when she was eight years old.

Due to financial difficulties, she was sent to live with an aunt in Penang in Malaysia.

She returned to the family when she was 15 years of age and later worked as a seamstress, factory hand, and a production operator for Hewlett-Packard.

In 1978, she married Benson Loh Ngak Hua.

She met Lim when her mother brought her to him to try and cure her of her bad temper and constant headaches.

Hoe believed in Lim’s “powers” and allowed him to administer electric shock “treatment”.

He also administered shocks to her husband, with fatal results.

Lim got away with this, claiming that Benson’s death was an accident due to switching on a faulty electrical fan.

Hoe fell into a deep depression as a result of her husband’s death and attended Woodbridge Hospital for psychiatric treatment.

She would later claim that Adrian Lim told her she was possessed and gave her electric shocks to drive out the devil.

She subsequently became Lim’s “holy” wife (invariably referred to as his mistress by the Singaporean press).


The Rape of Lucy Lau and Cult Sacrifices

Lucy Lau sold cosmetics door-to-door and visited Lim and Tan’s Toa Payoh apartment in October 1980.

Lim took an immediate liking to her and tried to convince her that she was spiritually possessed, offering to cure her through a sex-based ritual.

Lucy did not fall for this, but Lim accomplished his objective by mixing a heavy sedative into a glass of milk he gave her.

Lucy reported the rape to the police, and Lim was arrested and charged with the crime, while Tan was charged with aiding and abetting.

Both were released on bail awaiting trial.

Lim persuaded Hoe to state falsely that she had been present in the apartment throughout the visit and that no sexual assault had occurred.

In Singapore, rape is heavily penalized by lengthy imprisonment and mandatory judicial caning, so Lim was determined to avoid a conviction by any means.

Lim was a member of a religious cult that worshipped the Hindu deity Kali.

He came to believe that sacrificing human children to the goddess would bring him good fortune, bestow supernatural powers, and thwart the police investigation into the rape charge.

Hoe was tasked by Lim with procuring suitable child victims.


The Murders: Agnes Ng and Ghazali bin Marzuki

Agnes Ng Siew Heok (25/01/1981)

The body of nine-year-old Agnes Ng Siew Heok was discovered on the 25th of January 1981, stuffed inside a suitcase placed beside a lift on the landing of apartment Block 11 at Toa Payoh Lorong 7.

Hoe had encountered the little girl in a churchyard on the 24th of January and persuaded her to accompany her to Lim’s flat.

Once inside the apartment, the child was sedated with drugs, sexually abused by Lim, and suffocated with a pillow.

Her blood was drained into a cup, consumed by the three adults, and smeared over an altar picture of Kali.

Ghazali bin Marzuki (07/02/1981)

On the 7th of February 1981, a second child’s corpse was discovered lying between Blocks 10 and 11 at Toa Payoh.

It was that of Malaysian-born, ten-year-old Ghazali bin Marzuki.

The boy had likewise been lured away by Hoe and brought back to the flat.

There, the child was drowned in the bathtub, subjected to electric shocks from exposed electrical wires, and stabbed.

Lim and Hoe attempted to wash away the blood from the scene, but carried out the task so carelessly that responding detectives were able to follow a direct trail of blood droplets leading straight to the front door of Lim’s apartment in Block 12.

Lim, Tan, and Hoe were inside the flat when the police forced entry, where officers immediately spotted fresh bloodstains on the kitchen floor.

All three were arrested on the spot and charged two days later with both murders.

A thorough search of the flat yielded incriminating forensic evidence, blood traces, and an array of ritualistic cult paraphernalia.


The Supreme Court Trial (1983)

A preliminary hearing in the Subordinate Court took place on the 16th and 17th of September 1982.

Lim entered a plea of guilty and maintained that he alone was responsible for the homicides.

Tan and Hoe both entered pleas of not guilty.

In light of the compelling forensic and eyewitness evidence against the two women, all three were committed for joint trial before the High Court of the Supreme Court of Singapore on the 25th of March 1983.

The proceedings were conducted before Justice T. S. Sinnathuray and Justice F. A. Chua, sitting without a jury in accordance with Singaporean judicial procedure.

Deputy Public Prosecutor Glenn Knight led the case for the Crown.

Howard Cashin, J. B. Jeyaretnam, and Nathan Isaac appeared for Lim, Tan, and Hoe respectively.

The court declined to accept Lim’s unilateral plea of guilty, directing that a full trial on the capital indictment be heard.

Lim refused to cooperate with his defence counsel throughout the hearing.

The trial lasted 41 days, making it the second longest in Singaporean legal history.

Both Tan and Hoe mounted a defence of diminished responsibility, asserting that they acted under the complete mental domination and coercion of Lim.

Consultant psychiatrists were summoned by both the prosecution and the defence to evaluate and contest this plea.

Cashin also called psychiatrist Dr. Wong Yip Chong to argue that Lim suffered from an underlying psychiatric illness.

The trial concluded on the 25th of May 1983.

Justice Sinnathuray took 15 minutes to deliver the unanimous verdict of the bench.

In his judgment, he characterized Lim as:

“abominable and depraved”

Tan as:

“artful and wicked”

and Hoe as:

“simple and easily influenced”.

All three defendants were convicted of murder and sentenced to death by hanging, the mandatory sentence under the Singapore Penal Code, governed by standard statutory execution methods.

Lim smiled and politely thanked the bench, while Tan and Hoe showed little outward emotion.


The Appeals Process and Privy Council (1986–1988)

Although Adrian Lim declined to lodge an appeal against his conviction and sentence, Tan and Hoe pursued the full appellate avenues available under Singapore law.

The Court of Criminal Appeal (1986)

Their appeal was argued before a three-judge panel of the Court of Criminal Appeal comprising Chief Justice Wee Chong Jin, Justice Lai Kew Chai, and Justice L. P. Thean.

On the 4th of August 1986, the Court of Criminal Appeal dismissed both appeals in their entirety.

In addressing Catherine Tan Mui Choo’s appeal, the court held:

“We find that there is evidence that when she lived with (Adrian Lim), there were occasions when she suffered from depression. But, on a balance of probabilities, we find that at the time, when (she) took part in the two murders, she was not suffering from reactive depressive psychosis.

That which weighs heavy in our minds is that we had the benefit of hearing and seeing her give evidence in the witness box. The opinion we have of her is that she is an artful and wicked person. In conspiracy with (Adrian Lim), she was at all times a willing party to his loathsome and nefarious acts.

We have also considered her case on the footing that she was suffering from mental disease postulated by Dr Nagulendran. Even if she was suffering from abnormality of mind, we find that the abnormality was not such as substantially impaired her mental responsibility for her acts in the two killings.

In the case of the first appellant (Tan) we are of the opinion that, having regard to all the evidence adduced at the trial, the learned trial judges were entitled to conclude that on a balance of probabilities the plea of diminished responsibility had not been established.”

Regarding Hoe Kah Hong, the court observed:

“We now turn to consider the case of the second appellant, Hoe: In contrast to the first appellant the second appellant is a simple person who can be easily influenced. It is claimed that (she) is suffering from schizophrenia. Admittedly, there is a history of schizophrenia in her family.

There is also evidence that she was in Woodbridge Hospital from about the end of May to the first week of July 1980. That diagnosis is in issue between the psychiatrists. On the evidence before us, it appears that there are grounds for disagreement.

However, what comes out clearly in the evidence is that since her discharge from the hospital, some six months before the commission of the offences, she was thereafter at all times in a state of remission.

We accordingly have no difficulty in finding that even if the (second appellant) had suffered from schizophrenia, at the time of the commission of the offences she was not suffering from abnormality of mind as substantially impaired her mental responsibility for the two killings.”

The Privy Council and Presidential Clemency

Following their dismissal in Singapore, Tan and Hoe petitioned the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London, which declined to grant special leave to appeal.

Their final recourse was a petition for executive clemency addressed to President Wee Kim Wee, who rejected their pleas, leaving their death warrants to be signed.

This unyielding application of capital jurisprudence matched that of other notable Singapore cases, such as Angel Mou Pui-peng and Flor Contemplacion, operating within the framework detailed in capital punishment in the British Commonwealth.


Executions at Changi Prison (25/11/1988)

While on death row at Changi Prison, all three prisoners were counselled by Roman Catholic clergy.

Father Brian Doro attended to Adrian Lim’s spiritual welfare, later remarking that he found Lim to be a “rather friendly person”.

Tan and Hoe were cared for by Sister Gerard Fernandez, a Catholic nun who spent months counselling them.

According to The Straits Times, all three received Holy Communion before their execution.

On the eve of their hangings, they were permitted to bathe and were provided with cakes and soft drinks of their choice.

At 6:00 a.m. on Friday, the 25th of November 1988, their wrists were handcuffed behind their backs, and they were escorted the short distance to the gallows chamber inside Changi Prison.

Lim smiled as he walked to the scaffold; Tan and Hoe were described by attending warders as calm and composed.

On the gallows trapdoors, their legs were pinioned and black hoods placed over their heads, followed by the adjustment of leather-lined hemp nooses, utilizing the scientific drop principles established in the evolution of the long drop in the 20th century.

Singapore’s long-serving executioner, Darshan Singh, spoke his customary words to each of them:

“I am sending you to a better place.”

Just after 6:00 a.m., the drop fell, and all three were hanged simultaneously.

Father Doro conducted a Christian burial service, and all three bodies were cremated later that day.

Prior to Catherine Tan Mui Choo and Hoe Kah Hong, only two women had been executed in Singapore since independence: Mimi Sim for murder in 1973, and Loh Han Eng for drug trafficking in 1981.


Frequently Asked Questions

What were the Toa Payoh ritual murders?

The Toa Payoh ritual murders were the ritualistic killings of two children—nine-year-old Agnes Ng Siew Heok and ten-year-old Ghazali bin Marzuki—committed in an apartment in Toa Payoh, Singapore, in early 1981 by cult medium Adrian Lim, his wife Catherine Tan Mui Choo, and his mistress Hoe Kah Hong.

What was the motive behind the killings?

Adrian Lim faced trial for the sedative-assisted rape of cosmetics saleswoman Lucy Lau. Believing in human sacrifice to the Hindu goddess Kali, Lim convinced Tan and Hoe that sacrificing young children, drinking their blood, and offering it to the deity would bestow supernatural powers, bring good fortune, and halt police proceedings against him.

How were the perpetrators caught?

Following the murder of Ghazali bin Marzuki, the perpetrators attempted to clean up the crime scene, but left a visible trail of blood droplets leading from where the child’s body was dumped directly to the front door of Lim’s apartment in Block 12, Toa Payoh, where police discovered fresh bloodstains and arrested all three on the spot.

What defense did Catherine Tan and Hoe Kah Hong present at trial?

Both women argued diminished responsibility, claiming they were entirely under the hypnotic, physical, and psychological control of Adrian Lim. The court dismissed these arguments, concluding that Tan was a willing conspirator and that Hoe was in remission from her earlier psychiatric conditions.

When were Adrian Lim, Catherine Tan, and Hoe Kah Hong executed?

All three were executed simultaneously by hanging on the gallows at Changi Prison just after 6:00 a.m. on Friday, November 25, 1988, by executioner Darshan Singh.


Support the Archive

If you have found this article useful and would like to help preserve and maintain this historical archive, please consider supporting the site.